November 19, 2026 ・
Original Analysis

How to Govern When No One Agrees

A core premise shared by many different schools of modern political thought is that governance derives its validity from the will of the people. While this belief allows us to avoid answering more fundamental questions about the purpose of government, it makes it much more difficult to ground policy, as the will of the people is often fractured, contradictory, and changes over time. One school of thought believes that direct democracy is the standard for government, and even if not direct, all governance must strive to live up to the standard of direct democracy. Another school of thought believes that some things are too fundamental to leave up to democratic control, and that they must be protective, even as other regulations could be voted on democratically. Another school of thought thinks that any form of government where the people have meaningful control is inherently unstable, and the best that we can do is manage institutional decay, or remove the autonomy of the people. These schools of thought have answered this paradox in different ways, and each of them is important to understanding the future of governance and the complex dynamics that regulate our daily lives. 

The school of thought that is friendly to pure democracy is able to dissipate populist energy effectively while encountering great risks to structural stability. No limits on what the people can choose to do will create wealth redistribution and ill-advised central control for most industries unless the people are uniquely wise and self-controlled. This form of governance does let the will of the people be directly translated to policy, but the size of most societies means that this must be through some form of mediation. This method of pure democracy is rarely created institutionally, but it often exists functionally, as the people vote for leaders that they know will steamroll the governmental barriers put in place by law or constitution. A nation cannot persist on popular energy alone, and the problem with this form of government is that it often leads to the destruction of the nation itself, as the people often lack the information needed to understand which governance choices would be best for them.

The second school of thought holds that some things, like human rights and parts of government structure, are simply too precious to be left up for debate. These things are made either impossible or very difficult to change by the people, and there is an understanding that some specific, stable, structures are needed to ensure that a nation will persist. This school of thought recognizes that the alternatives to the country existing are often much worse than the problem of not letting the people have their will enacted on a specific policy. This form of governance takes into consideration national security, separation of powers, and federalism, to put the power of the national majority within a firm set of institutions. The people are given freedom and autonomy, but with limits intended to protect them from their own lack of sound judgment. This school often becomes quickly contentious, because the specificity of the guardrails must continually be tested, and they require agreement on explicit principles beyond merely popular consent. This causes many people to worry about whether this is true democracy, as they envision democracy as unbounded popular freedom. 

The final school of thought is a bit more pessimistic about human nature. They believe that, even if the people are given limits to their power, they will attempt to exert it until the bounds of what they can do are reached, at which point they will revolt. This school of thought recognizes that only a stable people can create a stable nation, and it is only a matter of time until the institutional reality catches up to the reality of the populace. Some people in this school of thought attempt to create a government that is powerful enough to resist the people‘s instinct to revolt. Other people who hold this belief put importance on supporting the people’s development of virtue. They believe that effective promotion of a virtue can stop the people from moving towards anarchy. Ultimately, all of these different beliefs stem from different interpretations of human nature, and how that relates to civic life. Understanding which of these beliefs any given politician has can help us know which sort of things they will be willing to justify. Each of these beliefs can appear very similar, but they have important consequences for how lawmakers will interact with existing institutions and the well of the people.

Download SchiffGold's Free Silver Report

Receive SchiffGold’s key news stories in your inbox every week – click here – for a free subscription to his exclusive weekly email updates.
Interested in learning how to buy gold and buy silver?
Call 1-888-GOLD-160 and speak with a Precious Metals Specialist today!