Was Popper Right Fiscally?
Carl Popper made two claims that are particularly relevant to fiscal policy: something is only a real science if it can be falsified, and a society must be tolerant of a wide range of ideas, as long as those ideas are tolerant of other ideas and will not fundamentally destabilize the nation. Popper was particularly interested in protecting individual freedom and people’s right to be wrong. He believes that the best society was one in which governments and private actors could continually test various hypotheses in order to understand whether they were right. His thought has been weaponized by the left to attack christian and right wing ideologies as a threat to society, and used by the right to argue for the dangers of Islamic immigration. The main theme of his work was never fiscal policy, but some of his concepts indirectly address it. The idea of falsifiability becomes extremely important as the economic modeling done to justify various tax or subsidy policies cannot be conveniently forgotten once the tax is enabled. Popper would have believed that the actual societal and economic effects of every policy should be carefully watched in order to determine whether it was a success or a failure, and allow future legislators to make better choices. The second part of his thought relevant to fiscal policy is his understanding of the allowable diversity of ideas. If some of the citizens hold ideas for government spending and tax policy that will fiscally destabilize our nation beyond what it can bear, should we let them vote? Popper believed that dangerous ideologies didn’t need to be put down by the state when they could be encountered by arguments from the other side. Given our society’s current levels of education and impulse control, there is a slim path that could allow fiscal conservatives to regain the favor of the public.
Popper believed that all government policy could be viewed as an experiment. If a policy was enacted with no clear way to see the effect, he would worry about whether it was a mistake destined to be repeated. So much of current fiscal policy is exactly this sort of unfalsifiable action. The effects of spending get tossed into the void of the national debt while the benefits of the policy are rarely understood as long as the special interest group that sponsored the bill gets paid. Popper would believe that our current system of complex and sustained government action was simply too complicated to meaningfully evaluate. Rather than humbly and carefully enacting new expenses, the state acts as though any new expense is justified, and keeps distributing money, even as we are nearing financial insolvency. The recent societal turn towards populism of all kinds means that centrally planned economic solutions are in vogue, making these careful experiments that Popper desired unlikely to be used.
The outcome of Popper’s second relevant axiom is a bit more difficult to untangle. He believed that all ideologies could be tolerated as long as they tolerated other ideologies and could reasonably be challenged by non-government forces. On the one hand, he wouldn’t see any threat to tolerance from fiscally loose ideologies, but on the other hand, he would see it as extremely destabilizing, leading to a set of unfalsifiable policies that would compound on one another if they were wrong, and would have no reasonable adversary until it was too late. Fiscal conservatism is simply too unpopular to beat economic populism outright in our current society of social media driven polemics. The last few decades have allowed people to experience an almost unending flow of government spending in a wide variety of forms. The return to even a yearly fiscal balance would feel painful for most people, as long as the government maintains its current levels of efficiency. While the state would never, and probably should never, disallow misguided economic ideas, it must create a mechanism for these ideas to be proven or disproven. Action at the federal level requires careful tracking and transparency to ensure that it doesn’t merely funnel money into the pockets of special interest groups.
As the economic realm becomes more centrally controlled, people who wish to promote economic liberty can think about how to make policies that could otherwise be endless money pits into things that can be falsified. The more regulations with a clear method of judging success, the more possible it will be to learn from mistakes and reduce spending. This method cannot save a country, but it can slow the descent.

